A funny thing about considering Green Day’s impact to the 21st century is how different I felt in 2003 compared to the following year. Had you asked the general population who they were, there was a chance that they had heard of “Dookie” but even then a lot of their appeal was in the past tense. Despite them releasing two of my favorite albums (“Nimrod,” “Warning”) prior to their resurgence, the consensus was that they were the ultimate hasbeen, another pop-punk band who could skid by on a handful of memorable hits at mid-sized venues. They weren’t THE band. They were merely another act.
To understand the impact of “American Idiot” today is to not fully appreciate the wrecking ball nature of its release. Before it became an era-defining classic alongside My Chemical Romance’s “Welcome to the Black Parade” with lyrics substituting as Myspace user names, it was the revitalization of rock that the George W. Bush administration needed. 9/11 was still a solemn day of memorial. The controversial wars had only started their madness. Meanwhile, the guys who turned a song about masturbation into a Top 40 smash was ready to take on a feat saved for artists like The Who and Pink Floyd. This was going to be an over-the-top magnum opus that captured the raw nerve of the young and very angry crowd who stood in the mosh pit singing along.
By 2004, pop-punk was barely reaching its experimental stage. The year prior found Blink-182 putting aside juvenile humor in favor of a moody, experimental and boundaryless work that nobody saw coming. Even then, Green Day had the one-up that few could top if for no other reason than it takes a lot to clear the bar.
I still remember the day that the band came into Los Angeles radio station KROQ 106.7 to premiere the album’s second track “Jesus of Suburbia.” My father had driven me to school and we sat in the car waiting and waiting for this song to come on. Then, with five minutes to first semester, I had to leave. The anticipation would have to continue a little longer, especially since no radio station was going to dedicate nine minutes to a multi-part rock opera in the middle of afternoon drivetime. Even then, it was like discovering a new form of breathing. The idea that a genre known for brevity could expand itself to unseen heights was exciting to a 15-year-old whose scope of music was still fairly limited.
It helped that the self-titled lead single was also one of those heart-rattling openers that translated the snot-nosed frustration into poetry. Alongside a music video that featured an American flag draped in green paint, the song ushered in an attitude that spoke to a generation. Decades later, I’d argue it was largely thanks to Tre Cool’s drum work, which had a jaunty opposition to the straightforward guitars. It also helped that Billie Joe Armstrong yelled lines like “Maybe I’m the faggot America” in a way that more than one high school student admitted to me was cool. This was the rebellion we needed. It was loud, fast, and catchy as hell.
Compared to most albums of the time, “American Idiot” is one that was inescapable. If you didn’t listen to Green Day, there was a chance that you knew of this record. Many could complain that they sold out or that their work wasn’t genuine, but there was no denying that it was the shot in the arm that rock music needed. There was a need to pack into stadiums (like I did twice on that tour) and sway your arms with Armstrong as he said, “Ay oh!” during the infectious breakdown. It was an anthemic cry of unity. It was the vigor which, as Lindsay Ellis once noted, has been missing in protest music during later administrations. “American Idiot” wasn’t just a record of the moment because of its anger. It was the crystallization of a moment because it stood for something.
It’s hard to fully remove the record from where I was at the time. I had started high school that year and was learning who my friend group was. On the Tuesday that it was released, I remember leaving campus and walking to two different music stores to hunt it down. When I didn’t find it at K-Mart, I walked another mile to Target where I bought “American Idiot” and The Killers’ “Hot Fuss” for a now enviable $15 price tag. Not bad for two records that still exist somewhere in my DNA (more-so the latter). From there, I had enough time to walk a mile back to a Carl’s Jr. where I sat in a corner booth while I first heard those notes. I pulled open the booklet and discovered everything for the first time.
To put it simply, I sat there believing that Green Day was back. I have the clear memory of thinking, “They’re going to be BIG.” In an era where rock music still resonated with larger markets, it was exciting to think that I was at the ground level for a phenomenon. I cherish that day so much that I refuse to buy a new record even though it’s scratched beyond any practical use. It sits as an artifact of a time and place. The sound fades, but the memory doesn’t.
This was the time when I discovered every song that would quickly be entered into The Millennial Canon. I don’t feel the need to go through every track so much as highlight what it felt like to hear “Jesus of Suburbia” for the first time.
In theory, it’s just a quick run of songs without any track cuts. There isn’t a lot of fluidity in transitions between a lot of the songs and the chord changes aren’t significantly congruent. While they present a larger narrative, it’s one that is present throughout the text. More than the song itself, the innovation could be found in how it managed to exist within continuity without resorting to intense levels of knowledge to understand. You could release “Holiday,” “Boulevard of Broken Dreams,” or “Wake Me Up When September Ends” as singles and not worry about a larger story being misunderstood. These were tracks that stood on their own and conveyed a band moving beyond pop-punk into theatrics and earnest emotions. They sang of disappointment and longing in ways that connected with the dourness of early 21st century American life. It was insightful within the repetition of choruses that twanged with haunting clarity.
On some level, “Jesus of Suburbia” was the song that ruined Green Day. The ambitious juggling of ideas necessitated the concept album to go as big and brash as possible. While I’d argue “Homecoming” is the better of the two epics, this was where things felt the most like The Who’s “Tommy.” This was the introduction of characters and themes that ran throughout the rest of the album. It created a whole world in each of its five sections that spoke to the punk ethos. You understood why the titular Jesus was recruiting people like St. Jimmy and Whatsername. Financial collapse and unending wars were the backdrop and the listener was now waiting for a Molotov cocktail to be thrown.
On the one hand, this is pop-punk at its biggest. The hooks on “City of the Damned” accompanied by the yells are breathtaking. Even the way that “Tales From Another Broken Home” transitions between soft and loud orchestration shows a band ready to alter the genre. Forget straightforward music. There was a need to challenge the listener and reward patience. This was a blissful reinvention of the 1970s where Pink Floyd would spend two hours making interpersonal commentaries about their childhoods alongside the dark subject of war. While Green Day was far from directly “personal” in the same sense, they were presenting something strong enough to give an emotional punch.
The issue with “American Idiot” is that it’s only one record that changed the scene. It’s the equivalent of capturing lightning in a bottle even for a band as accomplished as Green Day. What “Jesus of Suburbia” accidentally did was make audiences expect the platform to keep getting larger and the ambitions so grand that there was no way to actually top it. While I am a defender of “21st Century Breakdown,” it was clear that it was an effort to recapture the magic. Even then, chasing that same high was bound to fail and I’d argue lead to a messy late career period that’s more successful than it gets credit for, but still lead to Armstrong entering rehab before rediscovering what made them interesting.
But in 2004, “American Idiot” was the record that offered listeners hope for a future in music that was exciting. Alongside My Chemical Romance and Fall Out Boy adding their own theatrics, it was a time to see pop-punk enter new corners and present something more flamboyant. The evolution was so thrilling that it’s a shame how little it’s evolved since the early 2010s. Part of it is simply where popular music has gone, but it’s also that swinging for the fences so often leads to burnout that may be permanently damaging.
When I hear this record, it’s easy to see it as the definitive sound of the time. I had several magazines with the trio on the cover. Fuse TV was running constant interviews with them. Elsewhere, they were taking bands like New Found Glory, Sugarcult, and Jimmy Eat World on tour and playing to sold out crowds worldwide. I was fortunate to catch them twice. Even then, they were so omnipresent in pop culture by the second show (which was an add on date due to demand) that I was burned out even in being there. I had seen the act when it was fresher and felt like it changed my world. My shallowness came in being annoyed at how carbon copy it was… even if it was 25% different in the setlist.
“Homecoming” may be the unsung standout of the album. It has a lot more personality and I feel gets to the heart of why “American Idiot” resonated. Even having heard Green Day do songs like “Dominated Love Slave” and replaying it alongside excessive laughter, there was something to Mike Dirnt singing about falling asleep while watching Spike TV that was so evocative. To have that followed by Tre Cool singing “Rock and Roll Girlfriend” and joking about being an alcoholic with ex-wives only showed how big this world could be. It’s the type of track that makes you wish this was longer. Even if there was an earnestness that carried the rest of the album, I wanted those true punk antagonisms mixed in to make you see how crazy this vision was.
This may be what has saved later Green Day. Their humor is what made them more endurable than Blink-182. Even if the “Uno!,” “Dos!,” and “Tre!” weren’t well received, I’d still argue it’s their “Sandinista!” and has a home run of an album somewhere within. It’s one of their boldest, most mixed up collections to date that I think is the side effect of finally rebelling against the public’s perception of them. There would be no third concept record, or not to the levels of “American Idiot” and “21st Century Breakdown.” I’d argue “Saviors” does it in more subtle ways, but with more kookiness baked in.
When reading documents from 2004, I realized that “American Idiot” had one more significance attached to it. By coincidence, I was driven from that Carl’s Jr. to my middle school’s Confirmation night. To summarize, it’s a continuation of Catholicism where you take a class to learn more about faith and achieve the sacrament where you confirm that, yes, you are a Catholic. As I sat in the back row with friends, I listened to the presentation and discovered something. I had recently started public high school and was relieved to be free of religion. That night would be the first significant departure from the church for me.
I wouldn’t say Green Day inspired me that afternoon, though my interest in them probably spoke to that ideology. They were critical of groupthink organizations and longed for a certain freedom that I was only beginning to achieve. By rejecting Confirmation, I was starting my journey into a life that was more suitable for me. Maybe I wouldn’t worship “Jesus of Suburbia,” but I was entering a period of listening to new perspectives and wanting something more tangible. It was messy and incoherent at times, but I made it through.
More than the phenomenon of living through the success of “American Idiot,” I think it’s a record that spoke to a youthful expectation for the future that can’t be replicated now. I can’t listen to music and have the same heart-rattling experience that I did when I was 15. I’m too aware and jaded of what’s out there in the world. Okay, maybe 100 Gecs but that’s it. Whatever the case may be, “American Idiot” was the call to action that symbolized more than anything what happened in my life. It didn’t actually inspire me in any meaningful way, but it connected me to people who were curious to show me a world beyond my own.
How has it been 20 years already? Now I really wonder how Whatsername has been.
Comments
Post a Comment